Welcome, Guest!

Column: The season of protests

Tags:

By Carl Zielinski
Gargoyle staff reporter
Posted Friday, Oct. 27, 2006, The OG, opinions

[Note: This column has also been cross-posted on the Gargoyle staff blog. Click here for the entry.]

Protests, protests, protests. This really seems to be the only thing we whiny, bleeding-heart liberals
know how to do these days. Only problem is, they really don't work that well.

Have you ever noticed that all of the anti-war protests haven't done, well … ANYTHING? We're still in Iraq. We still haven't set a timetable for withdrawal. The president still can't say “nuclear.” But still, we get e-mails and see flyers advertising the newest reason why we should show up at the Union to send a message that people have gotten extremely good at ignoring. For example, I filter all e-mails with the word “protest” in it to a special “protest” folder, where they can be easily deleted.

Am I suggesting we just sit back and relax while thousands of innocent civilians are killed? Of course not. I, to some extent at least, have a soul. But the thing is, the more we assemble ourselves at mass protests, the less impact they have. Our chance to make a point by assembling has long since passed.

Here's a great example: the protest during the Republican National Convention in 2004. Did anyone happen to notice that BUSH WON THE ELECTION? Apparently not, because these futile displays of dissatisfaction have continued, and with alarming regularity.

But isn't it just so much easier to assemble and preach about how much we're doing than to actually ACCOMPLISH anything? Because that's what most of these anti-war protests seem to really be about, and that is what is truly disgusting about them.

Instead of having people take an active interest in politics (like persuading them to vote, for instance), these protests really just make Democrats, and liberals in general, into a party of complainers. All that accomplishes is making us sitting ducks for conservative talking heads, like Rush Limbaugh or Sean Hannity, who can slander us at their leisure.

The time for action has indeed arrived. A message does need to be sent to those in power that if they refuse to stop the violence against innocent Iraqis and Afghanis, we will remove them from power.

How, you ask? The midterm election on Nov. 7 is one great solution. Maybe more than 50 percent of the population could get off their collective ass and actually try to take back what should be theirs: the government. You could also get all of your community to write letters to your congressmen, demanding that we stop the slaughter.

But wouldn't it just be easier for us to assemble on the Quad, act indignant for a few hours, give ourselves a pat on the back for being so involved, go home, and act like we're morally superior to everyone else? Remember that when you see people assembling at around 12:30 Saturday afternoon outside the Illini Union for the “National Day of Action Against the Iraq War.”

Comments

Wow... someone who knows what they're talking about. *triple agreeage*

Change takes persistance. I'm not big into the protests myself, but I do see that going once and then giving up because it "didn't work" is doing more harm than good. Yeah, people should vote, write letters, etc., and we should definitely try to persuade them to do that, but there's nothing wrong with showing up at the Union to show people where you stand. Do you really want our generation to continue on its current road to COMPLETE apathy?

I completely agree! Those emails are annoying and those protests are going to do nothing but give you a reason to stand in the cold on a Saturday afternoon and feel like you're doing something worthwhile. Great article!

The point is that standing around at the Union really does nothing. Ever. Even if you go ten million times, do you think anybody's viewpoint is going to be changed? It's not apathy to talk to other people, debate with them, and vote. Especially if the protesters try to compell other people to join. What is worse is if people try to protest something, anything, just because its a cause and not because it's something important to them. No, standing around for every issue under the sun does not make you an activist.

Dear Carl, As you can probably guess, I disagree. As an activist who attends many of the protests you speak about, I will point out one crucial assumption wrong with your argument. Protesting is NOT all that we do. That is all you see, and that is mostly all I advertise to the Uni body, because as far as I can tell, most people do not want to put much effort into these things, and as you say, that is the easiest thing to do. Your article seems to imply that people would be interested in participating in political action if it was not through protesting, which they see as futile. Thank you for letting me know. I completely agree with you that we must get people out there to vote and we must get them to call their senators and representatives and tell them their views. That is exactly my goal and the goal of AWARE, etc. Know why they don't? Because people are very ignorant of a lot of these issues. People must first know about these things, about the Iraq War, about our support of Israel's foreign policy, about drug sentencing reform, about racism in schools, the full truth about them, talk about them, and only then will they be able to make a decision and vote. Protesting does one part of this. Of course I believe that protesting alone will not make change happen!! Parallely, I do everything I can to make the people around me aware of important issues- if you know me, you know I talk about them a lot. Carl, I do call senators and rep.s, I do talk about these issues any chance I get, I write articles, I go to lobby days. I am a member of AWARE, the organziation that got the two referenda on the November 7th ballot: you can vote on whether to impeach Bush and whether to pull out of Iraq. That is something ACCOMPLISHED. Now, people need to KNOW that they can vote on this on November 7th- that is why I was out at the quad today marching. I would urge you, Carl, to 1.)know what you are talking about- there is much more that I and other protesters do than just march. The fact that you don't realize that tells me that you have not taken the time to get involved with any organizations to find that out, although you imply that you do care. 2.)Don't approach these issues with scorn- your suggestions are GOOD- Go to Activism Club one day and share your creative ideas for eliminating political apathy in people and persuading them to vote. Thanks for writing this piece. Love, Shara

Carl, I understand your point. However protests are important for a variety of reasons. I have listed a few as follows. a.) Protests give people a sense of purpose. Say for instance old people and high school students who feel like their voice is extremely important in making fundamental decisions in the future of the world. b.) Protests are good for vehicle maintenance. In small towns like C-U we rarely get to honk our horns at traffic. Protests signs with commands to honk help blow all of the junk that may be in your horn out. This helps keep your car horn healthy, so if you ever move to New York, you wont need it replaced. c.) Protests also help upper arm strength. Holding up those heavy signs takes a tremendous amount of arm strength and muscle stamina. I, myself, have trained for protests. I do a variety of tricep dips, pushups, bench press, curls, and some core to help with the extra heavy ones. I finished second in the "Who can hold up a big sign the longest" Contest. I have the medal, I'll show it to you. d.) Protesting even helps with Physics!. You can witness the doppler effect as rushing cars with loud- and now rejuvenated- horns go by. For extra credit, you can even calculate the speed of the cars in relation to the speed of the change in pitch. How cool is that?! These are only some of the abundant benefits linked to protesting. It is important that you understand this topic before you go on ranting and raving about it. We have ACCOMPLISHED a great deal with protesting as is obvious by all this progress. I have a toned body now, a high self esteem, I'm a leading member in the Board for Automobile Horn Maintenance, and I even understand physics better! So please don't flout at us protestors, or treat us with disdain, come to our protests and you'' see how much gets accomplished. I appreciate this article very much. Love, Kareem.

carl, this article would be much less hypocritical if you had actually participated in ANY of these things. You obviously havent been to enough protests, to understand what they are really about. And yes i admit some are completely useless, i went on saturday, and there were like 10 people there. most likely it accomplished nothing. but protests like that set the stage for larger ones, ones that really show the power of the people; i went to New York for an anti-Iraq war protest before the war and seeing the 200,000 people standing, screaming, chanting, singing before the United Nations building truly was inspirational. Not just inspirational to me, but to all the people on the street, to get off their ass, make their vioce heard, and presuade others to do the same. If you were to take some time to understand the true spirit of activism and what it really aims to accomplish, come to any local or schoolwide activism groups, you might feel differently Marika

Okay; I just have to say this. First off, I am way too inexperienced to say whether or not protests are effective. They do seem to give some people a feeling of strength or kick-ass-iness, but I am a bit confused as to how effective they really are. If a group of 200,000 people "standing, screaming, chanting, singing" in New York to protest the war in Iraq were not able to effect the decision (did you see ANY hesitation from our leaders during the days prior to attack?) I'm not sure what would do the trick. Also, I feel that protests can be incredibly innappropriate and untimely. For example, the protesters that were actually INSIDE of the Republic National Convention were WAY out of line; I dont care how messed up the cabinet is, you dont sneak in to their "pep rallies" and insult them in front of their supporters. So, thats my two cents. But really Carl, nice job of ligting the fuse on a VERY debatable topic.

To kind of agree with Carl (for once!!), it's true. When I see protestors lined up on the sidewalk or in front of the Union, I think, "Great. Good for them." But if a protest actually made a difference, I would be really surprised. And has anyone else heard of people showing up to the funerals of American soldiers and protesting there? That is clearly going too far! Their families are upset already, and to have a bunch of screaming protestors at a funeral is completely preposterous. That may have been beside the point, but that's something I heard on the radio a few days ago that really made me mad. ~Michelle

Are protests effective?? They once were, that is for sure--look at the Vietnam war, CIW's triumph with Taco Bell, etc. One issue here is that obviously, a single protest is not what does it. It is years and years of persistence to effect change, which admittedly is frustrating, but that's dedication. However, I would love to discuss whether in today's world demonstrations really are the way to go. No, Bush and our current administration have NOT listened. They should, they definitely should for they are supposed to represent the people, and today the majority is against this war, but they do not. What ways can we make our politicians listen to us besides a full-on revolution, which I doubt most people are ready for?? I'd really like to organize an evening of discussion on this topic--we could have some presentations and then just open discussion, with drinks and food and a calm atmosphere for CONSTRUCIVE CRITICISM. Anyone interested??

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <b> <p> <br> <br />
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Word Verification
Please verify that you are human by correctly translating the image into text.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.