Column: United States, just a bully on the playground?

Tags:
bethanycolog.jpg

BETHANY HUTCHENS
Gargoyle staff reporter
Posted Friday, Feb. 2, 2007
Opinions

NEXT YEAR, AS all my friends, family, and people I'm on speaking terms with already know, instead of gathering up my books and heading off to college, I'm packing my bags for Venezuela.

I'll be staying with a host family and attending a local high school for 11 months. I'm very excited! But enough about me. This column isn't about my stay, but about my future host country.

Once I found out where I was going
(Rotary International, the organization that is sending me, does not guarantee placement in your first-choice country), I began extensive research on the culture, politics, economy, and people of Venezuela.

What I found out is slightly worrying. Writing in Insight Guide Venezuela, updated in 2004, Tony Perrottet described Venezuela's economy as being in “a state of crisis.”

Despite the country's huge oil revenues, big Western companies were grabbing most of the money. Poverty and crime were on the rise, and large sections of the capital city, Caracas, were not safe to even set foot in.

This is the problem that the country's controversial president,
Hugo Chavez, is trying to fix. Chavez, who was elected president in 1998, and was re-elected in 2000 and 2006, was a military officer who took part in a failed coup attempt in 1992 against then-President Carlos Andres Perez.

Chavez has already instituted reforms in his own country, such as vaccinations, road building, cheap housing, and adult education. Chavez believes deeply in his “Bolivarian Revolution,” through which he plans to nationalize key industries in Venezuela, including the lucrative oil industry; he is also actively encouraging other poor Latin American countries to do the same.

However, his sweeping changes in his home country are offset by his steady gain in power, beginning with a new constitution in 1999, which extended the presidential term to six years with a two-term limit and gave more power to the president, and culminating in a recent decision to grant Chavez complete power for 18 months.

The U.S. government is openly hostile toward Chavez, who is trying to cut down on Western influences in both the economy and culture of Venezuela. Chavez is also very critical of President George W. Bush. In fact, Chavez famously called Bush the “devil” in a speech to the United Nations in October.

Incoming Deputy Secretary of State John Negroponte said at his recent confirmation hearings that Chavez has been trying to export a brand of “radical populism.”

“I think that his behavior is threatening to democracies in the region,” said Negroponte, who is the outgoing director of national intelligence and a former ambassador to Honduras.

Given the United States' track record with countries that “threaten the democracy in the region,” this is the most worrying aspect of modern Venezuela. For some reason, the U.S. has it out for left-leaning democratically elected politicians in other countries.

In a creepily similar situation, the CIA staged a coup in Iran in 1953 to oust democratically elected Prime Minister
Mohammed Mossadegh, after he nationalized Iranian oil industries. The U.S. then propped up the Shah of Iran, whose autocratic rule led to the fundamentalist Muslim revolution of 1979 led by
Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. Many Iranian citizens were imprisoned, tortured, or killed as a direct result of the Shah's rule and the resulting backlashes.

Pretty much the same thing happened in
Guatemala, when the U.S. staged a coup in 1954 after the (once again) democratically elected Jacobo Arbenz tried to seize and nationalize unused lands belonging to the United Fruit Company, a U.S.- based banana company. The resulting chaos and disruption led to the creation of the Guatemalan death squads, which ravaged the country for years after.

Hopefully the CIA will restrain itself in Venezuela, although there have been ominous signs that the U.S. is already planning trouble. A new mission team for Venezuela and Cuba was recently created. CIA chief Michael Hayden has also stated, “The Hugo Chavez government in Venezuela is of prime agency concern.”

As someone who will eventually know, and probably love, a good number of people in Venezuela, I urge the United States to keep to itself on this one. Sure, we all need oil (at least until we wise up and believe in global warming), but are the lives of innocent Venezuelans really worth it? Can't we just let them have what is by right theirs?

Chavez may be power hungry, and he may eventually become a dictator, but as of yet he has not tortured, killed, or harmed any of his people, which is more than what most of the dictators supported by the U.S. over the years could say.

Comments

Fact: America is the greatest country in the world

Totally agree with you, Bethany. Bush better not pull anything in Venezuela. Wonderfully written article! Where in Venezuela will you be staying?

Are you serious? Anyway, everybody thinks that their country is the best, for whatever reason.

This is our country.

Personally, I think that blindly following anyone or anything is the epitome of idiocy. America wouldn't exist as a country if its founders hadn't questioned authority, and I don't think that we should take anything at face value. I'm not saying that we should revolt against our government; I'm not even being anti-government, per se. However, I don't think that it's a good move to simply say, "America is the greatest" without questioning current events, as well as other countries' policies. Fact: America isn't the only democratic nation out there, and fact two: we've done a lot wrong, especially over the last few years. I know for a fact that, in writing this, Bethany really researched all facets of the situation to make sure that she could present a full-spectrum image to all of you. Take whatever you want from it, but she's done a good job giving you the facts, and if you do want to be good Americans, you should consider them seriously. -Love, Jono

Well, "someone" too bad i never said that Venezuela was the best country anywhere during my comment. I know that that is far from the truth and am well aware of all the problems Venezuela has created and all of the ill choices that the Venezuelan government has made throughout the past 30 years. Considering my family moved here 13 years ago because they knew back then that the economic situation was only bound to get worse as years progressed and wanted to create a better living atmosphere for me. But hey! what do I know right?

Thank you Jono, you pretty much summed up what I was trying to say, that as American citizens it is our patriotic duty to protest what we think is wrong with our government's decisions. Obediance for obediance's sake is cowardice. In answer to Adriana's question, they haven't placed me in a city as of yet, I should hear anytime from now to June. Thanks for all the support!

Bethany, I know from those days I spent next to you in the Mac Lab as you worked diligently. I think the final result is pretty groovin'. Dig it. -Love, Jono

Adriana, I think "someone" was replying to Isaac, not you.

Sorry everybody, I should've been more clear. I was reffering to Isaac's comment.

I completely agree with Isaac.

Are you joking? America has the second-highest rate of ignorance and black-on-black violence of any nation in the world, next to Africa.

Oh yeah, and technically, Sweden is the greatest country in the world. Or something.

No, I'd have to say Sweden is around the second best country in the world. The first is the Netherlands. Sweden would be first if not for the general apathy and lack of motivation that the socialist society seems to cause.

How exactly do you quantify ignorance? -Ben

i was going to say that ben. also africa isnt a country

Wow, I might have to be a little less subtle next time I'm going to make a joke. While that previous comment was said completely in jest, I do think that the average American knows and understands far less about the world around him than the average citizen of any other first world (and perhaps quite a few third world) countries. No, this isn't quantifiable, but I'd say it's rather hard to ignore, much less refute.

Hi ! i'm a eighth grader at a current chinatown school. My teacher has given us a essay topic (is the united states of america a bully?)may i please ask you, other than the examples in that essay, what other events has occurred to make u believe that the united states of America is a bully? by the way, may i ask for the permission to include ur name and some of the informations and debate in my essay? Thank you!!!

Of course, if you would just email me any questions at bhutchen@uni.uiuc.edu, that would be great. Although, I have to warn you, I am not an expert on this subject. I do have my own opinions, and I know of several other incidences of American folly, but your paper should also include some research through credible sources. Feel free to quote my column, and, once again, if you have any questions or want to hear my views on the subject, feel free to email me.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <b> <p> <br> <br />
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Word Verification
Please verify that you are human by correctly translating the image into text.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.