Welcome, Guest!

Dining review: Timpone's Restaurant, an Italian jewel


The second-floor semiformal dining room, where weekend dinners should be reserved well in advance. Gargoyle photo by Jie Han (click to enlarge)


WHETHER IT'S LUNCH or dinnertime, Timpone’s Restaurant has a great selection of dishes for you to choose from. If you have some big bucks to drop, that is.

Entering the first floor of the Urbana restaurant, my family and I were greeted by a pristine and shiny bar (see photo below). At first, I thought that this was the restaurant itself, until I realized that Timpone’s was a restaurant, not a bar. Seeing the carpeted stairs, we decided to go upstairs.

Upon entering the dining area on the second floor, we were greeted by a maître d' who seated us promptly. Within a minute, we were each equipped with a menu and a glass of water.

Looking around, I saw that we were in one of three rooms — one hosted a private party, one had elegantly arranged tables and lights, and the last one was more dimly lit with a wine theme. Indeed, there was a wall of plaques from boxes of imported wines and a room in the back with a huge selection of wine. Though we were seated in that room, my younger brother and I were still not allowed to drink alcohol.

TIMPONE'S AT A GLANCE
  • Location: 710 S. Goodwin Ave., U
  • Hours: Lunch — 11:30 a.m.-3 p.m. Mon-Fri; Dinner — 5-10 p.m. Mon-Th; 5-11 p.m. Fri-Sat
  • Reservations: Suggested
  • Style: Italian
  • Price Range: $6-$30 per entree
  • Contact: 344-7619
  • Must Have: Fritto misto (fried seafood and veggies)
  • Rating: 9 on a scale of 10

All three rooms were populated by adults dressed either formally or semiformally — suits and dresses were the norm. Only one party of college students dressed casually, sporting T-shirts and hoodies. There was no music in the background, but the quiet chatter of the patrons was more than enough to make me feel at home, had my talkative brother been less excited.

Looking down the list of salads, appetizers, pastas, pizzas, and specials, I was amazed by the number of exotic ingredients and dishes. Red Snapper Meuniere? Grilled Mahi Mahi? Spinach Tagliatelle? Venison Ragu?

Ten minutes later, I ordered the house salad, the “fritto misto,” and the grilled filet mignon. After our orders were taken, we were presented with a plate of fresh bread and spiced olive oil. Breaking off a piece and dipping it into the olive oil, I felt my taste buds pleasantly stimulated by the richness of the spices, which were neither too spicy nor too bland.

Soon, our server returned with the house salad and fritto misto. The presentation of the salad was visually appealing (see photo below), with the herb vinaigrette drizzled over halved tomatoes, sliced carrots, diced cucumbers, chopped green beans, and other colorful field greens.

Munching on a forkful of spinach, I was pleasantly surprised by the flavor of the dressing. There was a tang of sourness mixed with just enough sweetness to balance out the taste. It was raw veggies at their best.

Next up was the fritto misto (see photo below). At a first glance, the dish looked like a bunch of extremely thin and curly French fries, drizzled with a white sauce and garnished with a lemon slice. Chunks of shrimp, scallops, calamari, and zucchini were sprinkled throughout the artistic jumble — deep fat fried.

Cleverly maneuvering my fork, I finally managed to pick up a few strands of batter-coated onions. The taste was quite reminiscent of onion rings, or onion-flavored French fries. The pieces were oilier than French fries, but the flavors of the original ingredients could still be discerned so that I didn’t feel too guilty for indulging my taste buds.

My most highly anticipated dish of the evening was the filet mignon (see photo below). It arrived about 10 minutes after the appetizers, along with the other main dishes. There was a large chunk of slightly charred meat underneath a white cheese sauce as the centerpiece — the filet. Underneath it was a brown sauce and thinly sliced eggplants, disguised amongst the colors. On the left and the right, there were two piles of cooked green beans. Two halves of two small potatoes were on the other sides of the filet, skin and all. Quite a well balanced meal.

A few moments later, I took up the extra-serrated knife and sawed off a mouth-sized section. Trying out the medium-cooked beef by itself, I found it was a bit bland and chewy. However, once dipped into the brown sauce and topped with the cheese, the filet mignon became much more than just plain meat. The flavors were richly spiced and were composed of just the right amount of the proper ingredients, leaving my taste buds wanting more.

Polishing off the rest of my dish, including the fresh and delectable beans and potatoes, I was quite satisfied with my meal. Well, minus the extremely salty eggplant at the bottom, which I don’t think I was supposed to eat.

At long last came the dessert — strawberry ice cream with sugar cookies. I was quite surprised when I discovered that I could still fit in some ice cream, given that there was quite a lot of filet mignon. Obligated to try out the pale pink scoops garnished with a sprig of fresh mint, I smeared a cookie with the ice cream. The mix was quite delightful and, though a bit too overpoweringly sweet, left me with a taste in my mouth that I would not soon forget.

The beauty of the meal? For about $25 per person, you can really treat a friend of yours to a luxurious dinner hard to find elsewhere in Champaign-Urbana.

Well, as long as you aren’t looking for a job as a runway model anytime soon.

More Photos FROM Timpone's


This is the first-floor bar of Timpone's. Gargoyle photo by Jie Han (click to enlarge)




House salad of baby field greens. Gargoyle photo by Jie Han (click to enlarge)



The fritto misto — nothing better than a side of fried seafood and veggies. Gargoyle photo by Jie Han (click to enlarge)



Medium-grilled filet mignon, by far the priciest main dish with a whopping $27. Gargoyle photo by Jie Han (click to enlarge)

Comments

yum yum yum yum yum yum yum

yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum......this is one yummy article. i really liked all the descriptions. btu i find it hard to believe that EVERYTHING tasted good.

Oh, keep it up, Jie

You've got a future in restaurant reviewing ahead of you - this was (in some significant ways) better than our local paper's reviewer. And thanks to your parents for making this review possible. And the pictures of the dishes were an interesting addition - although they also make it clear why food companies spend so much for food stylists - nothing looks as perfect in real-life photography as the stuff they set up for advertisements.

I'm sorry, but TImpone's

I'm sorry, but TImpone's isn't really Italian food. It's as close as we here in Urbana can come, but its the Tex-Mex of Italian.
It's still good, though.
I'm not trying to discourrage people from going there, but I feel that this article is incorrectly named,, as we have no true "Italian Jewel"s in C-U.

About being anonymous...

This is the kind of comment (deliberately inflammatory) that really should be credited. I don't necessarily disagree with your assessment of the cooking at Timpone's, but the tenor and quality of the article were both very good, and if you have an argument with either, you really should identify yourself - it's not that hard to do! (nor, for that matter, is editing a post).

David Porreca's picture

Borderline

I thought this particular post was borderline, but reasonable people can disagree with that assessment. As a general principle, after our previous era of free discussion crashed and burned in February, we don't publish anonymous posts that are clearly negative or inflammatory. This post came close to not making the cut, but in the future we might become stricter in the hope of further discouraging anonymity.

Isaac Chambers's picture

Resturant genre

It's really hard to classify many restaurants into a specific "genre," especially for the best restaurants, because that's what makes those restaurants so interesting -- it's a new mix of tastes.

But regardless, I think it's fair that Timpone's is classified as Italian seeing as something like Taco Bell is classified as "Mexican," which it obviously isn't authentic Mexican food. Do you think they have the Crunchwrap Supreme in Mexico?

Lauren Piester's picture

I love Timpone's

This has got to be my favorite sit down restaurant in town. The food is amazing.

Awesome review.

Gosh, now you've gone and

Gosh, now you've gone and made me hungry for Italian, JJ. Should have paid attention to the warning, shouldn't I?

You're descriptions are great and are definitely part of the reason that I'm beginning to feel hungry at near midnight. Darn you (just kidding), but now I must go procure a midnight snack.

Thanks a lot for the awesome review and keep it up!

Linda

Yummy (non-Italian) food, not greatest service

First of all, great review.

However, the times that I have gone to Timpone's, the service has not been as top notch as you got. However, I'd say it was just about worth it for the food. Not real Italian, but good food nonetheless.

Just don't go when it's busy if you don't like waiting for a table/bad service. I've found the service and wait time to be especially bad when it's busy.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <b> <p> <br> <br />
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Word Verification
Please verify that you are human by correctly translating the image into text.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.