Welcome, Guest!

Don't criticize what you don't understand

Ignorance is bliss? Not if it makes you look like an idiot, and that’s exactly how author Cooper Lawrence seemed in the eyes of video gamers everywhere following an appearance on a Fox News program.

On Jan. 21, Lawrence attacked “Mass Effect,” which by the way is a great game, for having “full digital nudity and the ability for the player to engage in graphic sex.”

First off, this is a complete falsehood. There is absolutely no “full nudity” in the game. There are a few scenes of love expression but the game never shows the full body; in fact, I think you only see someone’s stomach once. This all happens in cut scenes which the player has no control over while it’s playing.

“Mass Effect” is not a game about sex. It’s a highly engaging experience in an alternate, futuristic universe with a romantic subplot. Lawrence claimed that depictions of sexuality have a “desensitizing” effect on kids today. While that may be true with things such as pornography, there are virtually no video games that are sexually explicit.

Lawrence even admitted to not having ever played the game before. How can someone criticize something they’ve never seen? Movies and books can be easy to criticize since just about everybody has seen a movie or read a book and is well-versed in the topic. Video games, while having a smaller audience, are still a form of entertainment that requires knowledge of the topic in order to criticize it.

Though Lawrence did apologize in a New York Times article, the damage was already done, and gamers everywhere were irate.

This brings about another issue of knowing what you are talking about. In order to get revenge on Lawrence, hundreds of people posted poor user reviews on the Amazon.com entry for her new book, “The Cult of Perfection: Making Peace With Your Inner Overachiever,” which has nothing to do with “Mass Effect” or video games.

More than 400 negative reviews were posted and have since been removed. The negativity does not bother me; the content of those reviews does, however. Many reviewers admitted to not reading the book but rated it low because of Lawrence’s “diss” on “Mass Effect.”

I think after this episode in the world of gaming, everyone should do a little research before they criticize. I’m sure there are many other critics who obviously have no idea what they’re talking about, dealing with topics like politics. I’m not going to go into that, however — I don’t know much about it.

Comments

No photo provided

I Agree...

While it's true that some games with such things in them (Such as the Grand Theft Auto series or God of War) can have desensitizing effects, most kids can't get their hands on them, as said games are usually rated Mature or Adults Only (for good reason). Thankfully, the ESRB knows what it's talking about.

Laura Dripps's picture

Actually the ESRB is full of

Actually the ESRB is full of complete hacks. I bought Grand Theft Auto at the mall when I was twelve, after watching this dateline special where these kids with hidden cameras got away with it. It was pretty fun... I mean desensitizing and immoral!

But most people I know just got their parents to buy them those games.

No photo provided

Well if you truly did, then

Well if you truly did, then it's not the fault of the ESRB, it's the fault of the mall/store. Just because the game is rated M doesn't make up for the incompetence of the employee selling it to you. Although your second point is true.

I like the analogy of the

I like the analogy of the ESRB being related to the MPAA. While I'm under the age of 17, I still go to R-rated movies all the time, because it's just good business for the theater. There's a level of leniency that these businesses have that while at extremes would be harsh (say a 7 year old wanted to get into '300'). Also, in this sense I've never been asked for any ID when buying M-rated video games.

Anyways, what's really sad about the ESRB is that video games, as an emerging form of entertainment, always get the bad end of the stick. It seems like fundamentalists always want to talk about the corruption of youth in relation to these "sex simulations." The ESRB does what it can and still gets all this bad rep.

And as for Cooper Lawrence, it makes me proud to say I'm a gamer when I see hundreds of fellow "nerds" uniting under a common cause.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <b> <p> <br> <br />
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Word Verification
Please verify that you are human by correctly translating the image into text.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.