Welcome, Guest!
The pencil vs. the keyboard
Published: Tuesday, March 4, 2008 - 9:49pm
Computers are amazing. In particular, Word documents enable us to write faster, delete things quickly, and cut, copy, and paste. The regular old pencil-and-paper method is being used less and less.
My question is: Will it become obsolete?
When you really think about it, there are so many amazing things that we can do. Even as I’m typing now, I can rearrange my sentences, I can look up synonyms and definitions, and if I wanted, I could even print multiple copies of any of the documents saved to this computer.
Any of these functions would be impossible (or close to it) with a writing utensil and paper.
However, there are many problems with Microsoft Word. There are always the annoying zigzagged red and green lines. Usually, these are helpful to make sure I haven’t made a stupid mistake, but there are many times when I mistype a word like “off” or “with.” The computer can’t catch my mistakes because “of” and “wit” are words, too.
Then, making an outline for a paper is always a frustrating experience. The bullets never go the way I want them to, and I end up focusing more on them than the quality of my actual work.
That just sounds like I need to learn how to use Word better, doesn’t it? But shouldn’t it be easy to use? If my great-aunt Bertha-May-Esther-Pearl can’t even figure out how to turn a computer on, how is she supposed to use e-mail or upload pictures from the digital camera my great-uncle Seymour-Leonard-Eugene-Francis gave her for her 97th birthday?
Of course, technology is always changing, so I still think it’s possible that we may not be using pencils much in the future. Maybe sooner than later, I’ll be able to complete an outline with minimum stress-related hair loss. Maybe Microsoft Word will even become analytical enough to make the little paper clip pop up saying, “It looks like you’re making up family members with ridiculous names. Need some help?”




Comments
I think the pencil will
I think the pencil will be rendered obsolete by the mechanical pencil.
There are still uses for the pencil
Whilst I never use "regular" pencil by my own choosing anymore, certain evils, namely the SAT and ACT, require to use of such non-mechanical No. 2 pencils.
Actually, I really enjoy
Actually, I really enjoy typewriters, so the question is even more complicated.
typewriters
Yes, typewriters are super fun! I actually asked for one for my birthday last year, but I didn't get one. Maybe this year. ;)
I Second That
Since I use a typewriter for my library work (specifically, typing up spine labels), I can agree that, while they do tend to jam and be frustrating, they are awesome.
I must say, there is a
I must say, there is a feeling of solidity that comes with a typewriter that just isnt there on a computer.
I think that's what people
I think that's what people said when the quill and inkwell were first threatened by the fountain pen, actually. :-)
Go ahead and chase geese around all you want in search of the perfect feather, and I'll continue to enjoy my keyboards. I hardly ever write anything longer than a label by hand anymore. This has caused my handwriting skills to diminish over the years and my fine motor control to atrophy to some extent, but on the upside, I don't get the serious hand cramps that I used to when writing long papers with a pen. I gleefully pitched my last typewriter (an expensive IBM it was, too) as soon as I got a decent laser printer, and I have no regrets.
The formatting issues with outlines, bullets and so forth in MS Word are basically long entrenched bugs that everybody just accepts as "normal" nowadays, to the extent that Microsoft is now afraid to fix them for fear of making the behavior of their software "incompatible" with older versions. You really shouldn't blame your own level of experience or expectations for what was originally some hack's sloppy programming (probably even before Microsoft acquired the Word product from the original authors). There are better and easier to use text editors out there, so feel free to shop around a bit.
- GDS
Oddly, I actually find it
Oddly, I actually find it easier to at least start writing most of my papers by hand, with a pencil. I've found these really amazing pencils that are larger, so my hand doesn't ever cramp when I'm using them, meaning I can write forever. I was dying on the SAT without them.
When I write on paper, I find myself getting a lot less distracted, and for some reason it's easier for me to have things to say. I don't know why.
I love computers, but I also love just writing on paper. If we start doing everything on the computer, what will happen to all of the lovely doodling that keeps me awake during breaks from note-taking?
Post new comment