...the Sunset Rubdown album was overrated. It was nice enough but nothing special. Neon Bible (Arcade Fire) and In Rainbows (Radiohead) are both better albums than any of the ten you provided in my opinion. They're all either pretty good or even great albums (Boxer and The Reminder particularly) but the list is flawed, IMO.
The First List is OK, but...
...the Sunset Rubdown album was overrated. It was nice enough but nothing special. Neon Bible (Arcade Fire) and In Rainbows (Radiohead) are both better albums than any of the ten you provided in my opinion. They're all either pretty good or even great albums (Boxer and The Reminder particularly) but the list is flawed, IMO.