Uni wins 10th WYSE Academic Challenge state title in 11 years

Gargoyle photoMembers of Uni's WYSE team gather for a photo at the Illini Union today shortly after winning the WYSE Academic Challenge state championship for small schools. All students are seniors. Front (from left): Jessica Stark, Angela Jin. Seated (from left): Ethan Berl, Lucy Zhang, Jake Seeley, Julian Hartman, Geoffrey Beck, Ruth Welch. Standing (from left): Larissa Pittenger, physics teacher/team sponsor Jim Carrubba, Joe Leigh, Jennifer Roloff, Linda Song. Team members not pictured: Sarah Pfander, Mike Renner.

WYSE COMMENTS
First-place winners Jennifer Roloff,
Joe Leigh, and Ethan Berl talk about the value of competing in WYSE.
Click to listen (1:27)

URBANA — For the 10th time in 11 years, Uni High is the state champion among small schools in the Worldwide Youth in Science and Engineering (WYSE) Academic Challenge.

A team of 14 seniors coached by physics teacher Jim Carrubba won the Division 300 title this afternoon at the Illini Union.

In all, 450 students from more than 20 schools participated in the annual competition, which consists of 40-minute tests in seven different academic areas: mathematics, chemistry, English, physics, engineering graphics, biology, and computer science.

Three Uni students won first place in individual categories: Ethan Berl (computer science), Joe Leigh (math), and Jennifer Roloff (physics). For placing first, the students will each receive a $2,000 scholarship if they enroll in the University of Illinois College of Engineering.

On the same condition, the College will award $1,000 scholarships to Berl, Leigh, and Geoffrey Beck for their second-place showings: physics (Beck), math (Berl), and computer science (Leigh).

"To me the value of a contest like this is you can really sort of gauge yourself against — in this case — everyone else in Illinois in a subject that I really enjoy, engineering," said Leigh.

To reach today's finals, schools had to advance through regionals in February and sectionals in March. Division 300 is for schools with enrollments of 300 and under. Other divisions, which will compete later this week, are 700, 1500, and Unlimited.

From 1998 to 2006, Uni won nine consecutive Division 300 titles. Last year, Carrubba and his team decided to compete in Division 700. Uni (470.7) finished second to University of Chicago Lab High School (484.6). In Uni's absence, the 2007 champion in Division 300 was Keith Country Day School, located in Rockford.

This year's team results were:

Competitors who finished sixth and above in their categories won medals. Uni students placed in the following subject areas:

Mathematics

  • 1st place: Joe Leigh (tie with student from another school)
  • 2nd place: Ethan Berl
  • 4th place: Julian Hartman, Jessica Stark (tie)
  • 6th place: Mike Renner (tie with student from another school)

English

  • 6th place: Jake Seeley (tie with student from another school)

Physics

  • 1st place: Jennifer Roloff
  • 2nd place: Geoffrey Beck (tie with student from another school)
  • 3rd place: Julian Hartman (tie with student from another school)
  • 5th place: Jake Seeley
  • 6th place: Jessica Stark (tie with student from another school)

Biology

  • 5th place: Angela Jin (tie with student from another school)

Computer Science

  • 1st place: Ethan Berl
  • 2nd place: Joe Leigh

Uni's 2008 WYSE state finals team consisted of Geoffrey Beck, Ethan Berl, Julian Hartman, Angela Jin, Joe Leigh, Sarah Pfander, Larissa Pittenger, Mike Renner, Jennifer Roloff, Jake Seeley, Linda Song, Jessica Stark, Ruth Welch, and Lucy Zhang.


Comments

old division?

so now Uni's back to the 300 division...unlike last year when the team went against unlimited and had the chicago lab school. why did we change?

David Porreca's picture

WYSE

Mr. Carrubba can address your question better than anyone, but let me point out that Uni has never competed in the unlimited category in the WYSE state finals. That last bit ("state finals") is important. Uni competes in the unlimited division at the regional and sectional level, mainly to allow other small schools a chance to advance. But at the state level, Uni has competed in the small-school division (Division 300) every year except 2007, when it competed in Division 700 and placed second to U-High Chicago.

Uni has competed in WYSE since 1996, when math teacher Carol Castellon was the team's first coach. At the state finals Uni placed third in 1996, second in 1997, and first in 1998, which began a string of nine consecutive state titles.

Comments from the Coach

I have a zillion* (*OK this number is not scientifically accurate) things to say about WYSE, beyond the obvious, namely that I am extremely psyched and pleased that we took another 300 title this year. I could tell you that Uni has tremendous structural advantages, especially as compared with other small schools: even when we do poorly in some categories (no medals in Chem this year and only one 6th place in English) we have enough strength to carry us, unchallenged, to a title. I could tell you it's actually kind-of awkward to carry off yet another huge, flimsy, plastic trophy, knowing how little we did to prepare and how much of a struggle it is for other small schools just to make it to state. Most of all, as a coach, I could tell you how much fun I have, not just in the "hospitality suites" the venues set up for us hard-partying teachers, but hanging out with the team at the various sites. (My only regret this year: leaving the pizza place "early" and missing out on the picture games.)
Instead, I'll tell you all about 2007.
Last year the WYSE authorities took me completely by surprise when they announced that top finishers would be receiving scholarships to attend the U of I College of Engineering. Money changes everything. We are pretty much the only school in Illinois with a serious chance of beating Chicago Lab (bigger schools being forbidden from dropping into the lower divisions) and I'd love to do it; we can beat them if we take the tests seriously. But I'm not going to throw away potential dollars just for the sake of pride. If you're sick of faculty families complaining about paying for college out of their >$200k annual compensation, consider that many Uni families do not fall into this category. Until parents start telling me they'd rather see us beat bigger schools than save thousands of dollars in tuition, I say we stay in 300, where we are more likely to earn first- and second-place finishes.
If this doesn't sound socially responsible, then convince the College of Engineering to find a less-lazy way of handing out WYSE-based scholarship dollars. My obligation is to Uni's team. At least one of our team members just earned $3000 and I'm glad he did.

I understand your reasons,

I understand your reasons, and yes, this time we won a lot more because it was much much more likely (the record says it all). Like you said, the team studied little since there doesn't seem to be much competition. It's too bad that the money is limited to only the UI school of engineering.

I wonder

I wonder how competitors from other schools might feel reading these comments. "We don't bother to prepare, and we still walk in and take all the top prizes." Doesn't that seem boastful, a bit arrogant and unsportsmanlike, and even elitist?

Yes it does.

We don't take all the top prizes---not even close to a majority of them---but your criticism is valid and appropriate and well-taken. It does sound awfully elitist, which I had not intended. As I said, the fact is that Uni has tremendous structural advantages over other schools in the small division, even over other highly selective ones. I think the 700 division is a much better and much fairer fit for a school that gets to admit competitively from an extremely strong applicant pool; that's why we were there last year. But now there's money on the line.

WYSE

It's almost as if Uni doesn't take this WYSE competition seriously at all. The money isn't exactly supposed to be the point of the competition, is it? I guess in Uni's case, it is, and perhaps that justifies the fact that the team doesn't challenge themselves at all by going to this division. However, what's so great then about Uni winning so many? It was pretty much expected...

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <i> <b> <p> <br> <br />
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Word Verification
Please verify that you are human by correctly translating the image into text.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.